For the past 5 months, I have spent a significant amount of time online thanks to the Sprint Novatel U720 USB modem. The modem - which operates seamlessly on both Windows & Apple hardware - is the perfect companion for anyone looking for true mobile broadband. Due to the fact that Sprint’s EVDO network operated flawlessly [providing amazing connectivity speeds], I had never made it a point to nit-pick each line of the monthly bill. Curiosity got the best of me once I could no longer justify a $2-5 fluctuation (difference) at the end of each billing cycle. Lo and behold, what I noticed was enough to make me scratch my head in bewilderment…
The Sprint Novatel U720 USB modem is assigned a standard phone number. However, the phone number is not a true phone number in that calls can be made / received or messages sent / received. The number is more of a convenience for Sprint / Nextel - simplifying network-wide account management. Anyone who dials the assigned phone number will be prompted to leave a voicemail. Tomfoolery! My EVDO modem has no keypad, screen, or way to alert me of missing calls or messages! Yet, monthly bills include taxes and surcharges which would should only be associated with actual cellphones. Right? Four charges immediately jump out:
Additional Sprint Charges:
- Federal-Fed. 911 Fee ($0.40)
- Seattle City-Utility Users Surcharge ($3.82)
Government Fees & Taxes:
- Washington State-911 Taxes ($0.20)
- King County-911 Taxes ($0.50)
The “Seattle City-Utility Users Surcharge” requires a little more research, but the 911 fees are questionable. Again, the Novatel U720 USB modem is not a phone, nor does dialing 9-1-1 on the make-believe keypad before placing it against my head improve my chances of being rescued in an emergency situation. I rang Sprint customer service in search of an explanation.
Looking for answers, on hold with Sprint CSR’s
Sunday morning I phoned Sprint customer service looking for an explanation as to why a data-only wireless modem account would be pinned with 911 fees & taxes. The general answer from the first tier of service reps was "I don’t know…". Standard customer service reps are unable to explain Additional Sprint Charges or Government Fees & Taxes. Apparently, it is standard for any Sprint account "handsets" to have 911 taxes & fees. A soft-spoken representative named Margaret recommended that I call Corp. Security at 1-800-877-7330. Unfortunately, Corp. Security dealt with fraudulent charges, personal security, and general "report a stalker" scenarios. A second representative by the name of Bernie recommended that I call the 1-866-770-6690 which handles Surcharges & Fees.
The number which dealt with Surcharges & Fees (1-866-770-6690) was of little help considering the entire process is automated with ZERO options to speak with a service professional. The automated system walks callers through three different informational recordings dealing with the 1) Federal wireless local number pooling and portability surcharge, 2) Federal E911 surcharge, and 3) Federal Universal Service Fund Surcharge. Sprint has some background on mandated charges here but provides little support for speaking to someone face-to-face concerning the charges.
Thinking "3rd time’s a charm", I phoned Sprint a third time and spoke with Franklin. Franklin informed me that the 911 fees and Federal / State taxes are a requirement and that there is nothing that can be done. However, he did mention that I am being charged 911 taxes too many times. I guess I’ll get a few cents reimbursed for the current and previous billing cycles. Unfortunately, little information was provided concerning the "Seattle City-Utility Users Surcharge".
Understanding 911 fees & taxes requirements
Taken from Support - Taxes, fees, and other charges, Enhanced 911 is:
[...] a technology that will help emergency response agencies determine the location of anyone who dials 911 from his or her enhanced wireless phone. Sprint is upgrading its network and handsets in order to meet federal requirements and ensure that the most advanced 911 technology is available to customers.
I am aware of the fact that Sprint is required [by law] to pay certain local and state taxes. However, should wireless EVDO customers be pinned to pay the same regulatory 911 fees and taxes put in place for the security of standard wireless phone customers? I’ll continue footing the bill in hopes that in the event of an accident, I can wave my EVDO modem in the air in order for emergency personnel to pinpoint my exact location after I dial-out. [digg this]

Jonathan Solichin
May 28th, 2007
Quote
Wow, that is horrible. Paying $5.00 for something that you can’t use really sucks. I hope you’ll get some benefit out of it one day…(laughs). Great informative read. Thanks for sharing.
Myke
May 28th, 2007
Quote
Ha! Don’t you just love the run-around when trying to get a hold of someone that can answer a question beyond “How many minutes do I have left?” Oye, customer service gives me a headache.
Nick
May 30th, 2007
Quote
That sounds bogus to me. I’m not sure how the rest of your Sprint experience has been, but I can tell you mine was less than pleasant.
Arnold
May 30th, 2007
Quote
Thanks for sharing Derek. This just teaches us (consumers) to more carefully check our monthly bills. You will never know if/when you get overcharged, unless you do so otherwise.
Lawrence Cali
May 31st, 2007
Quote
Hi Has anyone been able to determine what the “city utility users surcharge” is on a cell phone bill. ATT wasn’t sure , just read something that wasn’t really an exp[lanation. City of Seattle Utilities Department didn’t know now did the City Finance Dedpartment.
Thanks
Zacharias
Jun 1st, 2007
Quote
Sprint’s recently rolled out an all-one-can-eat combo that includes using a EVDO device unlimited-like, in addition to go-fourteenyearoldgirl nutso unlimited calling and SMS. I think it’s around ~$120 (mileage varies by market), and this may save you a few bones versus paying sprint (or someone else) for a non-bundled plan.
Some unscrupulous folks have found using electronic billing + moving the billing address to somewhere with no local/state cell taxes (AZ, don’t quote me on that) can eliminate some of those pesky nickel-and-dime fees you’re incurring, as well.
jdoc
Jun 7th, 2007
Quote
I think Sprint is required by law to charge that just because it’s a telecommunications company.
It could also be that all data cards have E911 Triangulation in them, which is still a form of 9-1-1 but without voice. It is used in extreme cases (when a person goes missing, for example), with a judge’s approval they can pinpoint your location.
Still sucks to pay for that, tho.
Trackback
Jun 7th, 2007
AlbanyWiFi.com » Blog Archive » 911 & City-utility surcharge on a data-only EVDO card?
Zacharias
Jun 11th, 2007
Quote
They’re required to pay based on subscribers. They’re not required to charge you for that. They could just as easily call it “the cost of doing business,” but instead, you get yet another (passed along) cellphone misc charge.
Trackback
Jun 13th, 2007
911 and City-Utility Surcharge On A Data-Only EVDO Card « EMONOME